Monday, September 26, 2016

Regarding a Certain Posture

When I think of the lyrics, …the Land of the Free and the Home of the Brave, I think of the men and women, known and unknown, who survived and fought for the right to be treated as equal citizens in the eyes of the law and in the hearts of their fellow Americans. Rev. Dr. King, of course, and Ida B. Wells and Cesar Chavez and so many others. The slaves who survived, the Chinese railroad workers who endured, the Jews who preserved, the Filipinos and Hmong and name a country, name an ethnicity, name a people who were once treated as less than and/or taken for granted and whose condition has now, (no matter how slightly), improved.

When I see the Stars & Stripes, I have no problem standing for these people. I have no problem standing to acknowledge where we are and how far we have come as a nation.

********************************

Many of us still kneel to pray, to humble ourselves before our God.

It is still, as far as I'm aware, the posture folks assume when proposing marriage to their beloved.

Reminiscent of what we imagine of medieval knights of old, the posture is not the issue.

There is nothing disrespectful about kneeling.

********************************

In the presence of my country's flag, it is also right to honor and remember of those who may not have survived the cruelties of the United States. For the Trail of Tears and other massacres. For those unknowingly subjected to government sterilization. For nationwide Jim Crow laws. For the soldiers who fought abroad for the freedom of others and came home to either derision, second class citizenship, or both. For law enforcement officers shot in the line of duty, or murdered because of their uniform. For civilians killed by law enforcement, civilians who were not instructed to drop a weapon or given enough time to comply, who were shot in the back, who died for not opening the car door quickly enough.

To honor these people, it would not bother me to kneel.

********************************

At this point, if you're still upset, you may have an issue with the audacity to use so public a forum to silently proclaim America's continuing imperfections. There's a proper way to protest, you may insist, forgetting that the nature of protest is never proper, that it is a disruption of the status quo. Or you may feel it's unpatriotic, forgetting that love of country is not simply embracing where it is but also but pushing it to be better.

At this point, if you're still upset, it's not about the posture. It's not about the kneeling. It would be disingenuous to claim so.

Monday, March 28, 2016

Help Me Understand: LGBT Discrimination

My fellow Christian Americans,

I understand there is biblical mandate against homosexuality.

What I don't understand is forcing people into desperate circumstances. What is the purpose of

--Reducing or removing a person's ability to earn a livelihood? or

--Denying health care to a child being raised by same-sex parents?1 or

--Denying financial security to a long term couple when one of them dies? or

--Denying a member of such a long term couple from making medical decisions for the other person?

Is it an attempt to kill people through legislated marginalization? To force a hopelessness so deep some would consider suicide?

If so, do you believe you are greater than God, who has given life to all, including the people you loathe?

Is it an attempt to force people to live according The Law, despite many not being of the Faith? Let's not ignore the fact we don't even try to live according to The Law ourselves.2 Are you holding others to a higher standard than you hold yourself?

Is it an attempt to try to change people? To use fear and misery to force others to behave as you want them to?

Help me understand.

Because here, in the United States, we don't live in a theocracy3. Our constitution expressly states that the government shall not establish a national religion. And while we may write or support laws which are biblically based, we cannot use government to force the Gospel or a "Christian lifestyle"4 on others. Mainly because

a) It ceases to become the Good News, instead morphing into Follow My Interpretation (Pharisee, anyone?), and most importantly,

b) That's not how the Gospel works. The Good News has never had to be forced upon or enforced among those who sincerely believe.

So why do some of you support, advocate for, and/or enforce of such discrimination?

Please. Help me understand.




1. Seriously. How many of you remember when you chose your parents? Then why punish the child for something over which they had no control?

2. Bacon, people. And ham. Some of us eat shrimp. Many of us would eat a bacon-wrapped shrimp appetizer in a heartbeat. All of which is contrary to The Law.

3. Nor do I want to live in a theocracy. Imagine all of the petty church arguments writ large. Imagine the group in power mandating how one praises, what one wears, what type of music is allowed. No thank you. It's hard for me to see man-made theocracy as anything other than authoritarianism attempting to disguise itself as religious purity.

4. That's right, I used quotes. Because when we say and think "Christian Lifestyle", we often go straight to one's behavior and ignore the heart. We sometimes get caught up in the appearance of propriety and spirituality, and condemn those who actually exhibit the heart of Christ. We forget that a Christian Lifestyle, a heart guided by Christ, is not always packaged as the smiling face you see in the church vestibule.

Help Me Understand: Transgender Bathroom Issues

So, in Charlotte, North Carolina, the city council passed an ordinance that, among other things, allows a transgender person to use the public restroom of the gender they identify with.

Aghast, the state legislature overrode this portion of the ordinance with a law forbidding municipalities to enact anti-LGBT discrimination laws. Some state legislators claimed Charlotte's ordinance would allow sexual predators to use the law as a means to assault their victims.

Never mind that men who've assaulted women in public restrooms never needed a guise before. If there is to be a ruse, the color of authority is much more effective, as a recent case has shown.

Just to be clear,

The North Carolina state legislature wants all biological males to use the men's restroom, and all biological females to use the women's restroom (that is, restrooms maintained by a municipality or government entity).

Even if some of those biological males dress and look like women, and some of those biological females dress and look like men.

The legislature wants a biological male who dresses and looks like a woman to go to the bathroom with men. A woman-looking person in the men's restroom. Making the men in the restroom uncomfortable.1

The legislature also wants a biological female who dresses and looks like a man to go to the bathroom with women. A man-looking person in the women's restroom. Making the women in the restroom uncomfortable.2

Again, just to be clear,

Basically, the North Carolina Legislature wants everyone to be uncomfortable in a public restroom.

Why?





1. Not to mention possibly putting said woman in danger. You know how some men will aggressively try to hit on any woman within a 5 inch radius of where they are standing? Could you imagine? A publicly owned sport facility or concert arena? A lot of alcohol? A woman in the men's bathroom? It would be a wonder if said woman (biologically female or not) didn't get assaulted.

Wednesday, September 2, 2015

Re: All Lives Matter

I posted a little something on Facebook at roughly 5 am, with the thought, Right. I'll fix it in Post. And so, after more than 12 hours of percolation, I present a less rough cut of the idea that Black Lives Matter and Blue Lives Matter are not mutually exclusive sentiments. Please enjoy.

In a Facebook post about the recent murders of law enforcement officers, Frank Somerville, a Bay Area news anchor, noted

Not all police are bad.
And not all young black men a criminals.
And I think we all need to realize that.

I would modify his statement to say not all black people are criminals, but in essence, his point is what I've tried to make in previous blog posts.

See, if you post an item to social media with language like but cops shoot black criminals and people are up in arms,

I get the impression you don't understand the second line of Mr. Somerville's statement. It would seem you believe that when law enforcement chooses to interact with a black person, that black person is automatically, and perhaps inherently, a criminal.

That belief is a lie.

Some of the negative assumptions about who black people are (and what black people deserve) are at the root of the incidents which spurred the term Black Lives Matter. To refute with All Lives Matter ignores both our history AND our present. All Lives is something to aspire to, not something that is.

Because if all lives truly mattered, we wouldn't tolerate the racism, sexism and classism which exist in our society. If we truly believed all lives mattered, we would act accordingly. To insist All Lives Matter is the current state of affairs is an exercise in delusion.

But

If by stating All Lives Matter you are expressing a desire or determination to turn a dream into reality, you are echoing the sentiment of Black Lives Matter. For in a small way, that is what the movement seeks to do.

One more thing.

It's easy to fall into the mutual exclusivity trap. It may seem the friend who posts tons of pro-Black Lives Matter stuff doesn't care about Blue Lives,
and the friend who posts tons of pro-Blue Lives Matter stuff doesn't care about Black Lives.

But unless they've told you as much – either directly or via the comments they've posted – you have no basis for such an assumption. The two sentiments are not mutually exclusive.

Instead, consider such friends as being on one of the many fronts of a battle to protect innocent lives.

Thursday, July 23, 2015

The Dangers of Facebook

This meme was in my Facebook Newsfeed one morning




<deep sigh>

If you believe Walter Scott and Tamir Rice were criminals, I don't understand you. It's not that we can't talk about other things, but on this point, we'd need a Rosetta Stone.

If you imply the most recent protests are rioting, I disagree with you with the same level of disrespect with which you make such an inference.

That non-batting of the eyes you are witnessing is due to Mainstream Media's focus on Donald Trump. Voices raised over yet another filmed example of systematic racism have nothing to do with it.

And to imply

Believing Walter Scott's death was unjust = Yawning over service members' deaths at the hands of lone gunmen

Is to set up a false equivalency.

Humanity has the capacity to be alarmed at two different but equally tragic instances of murder. Let's not shortchange ourselves by pretending otherwise.

On Bland and Cosby

On Sandra Bland
From what I can tell, Sandra Bland's crime was having an attitude, for not knowing her place.

One thing's for sure - I'm going make sure my door is locked next time I'm pulled over.

You know there's something wrong when a law abiding citizen is afraid of being pulled over for a broken headlight.


On Bill Cosby
The pain of it is, he was such an influential man, so integral to the fabric of our entertainment landscape.

Did you know he was the first African-American to win an Emmy, for I Spy? A TV show that featured him as an equal to Robert Culp?

Did you know that before he demanded otherwise, white stuntmen would do their jobs in blackface when stunting for a black actor?

He is part of the pantheon of great comedians; many who were influenced by Pryor were equally influenced by Cosby's storytelling.

The Cosby Show put me on TV. As a middle class black girl, I saw my family and aspects of my world in the show. All of the other black family shows used 'the ghetto' as a reference point. I cannot overstate the importance of seeing yourself reflected in the mass media. In retrospect, I felt a little less different and alone because of it.

And after A Different World, what was the next show to focus on life in college?

Disheartening is too soft a term.

How could one who helped pave the way be so horrifyingly insecure?

Re: The Confederate Flag


1. TVLand shouldn't have pulled The Dukes of Hazard off the air. As a reflection of its times and the reason why so many of us begged our parents to let us get into the car through the window, it's fluff entertainment. If the network was that concerned about the presence of the flag, they shouldn't have put the episodes into rotation in the first place. So it'll be back on the air in what – August? September?

2. What we call the Confederate Flag has always been a symbol of White Pride and White Supremacy. It may not have been conscious for some, but that is the Heritage which is celebrated. Why else has it been so prominently used by the Klan and Neo-Nazi groups? Why else did it gain prominence in the wake of Brown vs. the Board of Education?

3. We should all probably (re)watch Ken Burn's Civil War.

4. I get that some white Southerners were indeed fighting for the little they had. They didn't own slaves, and the economic benefits of slavery didn't trickle down to them. They were likely conscripted into service, or were paid to take a wealthier person's place. Maybe for some, the Confederate flag represents what the family went through, the war they survived?

5. Changing the names of schools and statues and bridges and streets, etc. should be on a case by case basis. Let's not be like the Taliban, destroying the history of a region. We need not celebrate it, per se, but it could be informative, instructional. It's important to know that such and such statue was erected in the days after Reconstruction, when lynchings began to increase. Or that the bust of so and so came to be displayed prominently in the State House after schools were ordered to integrate. In some cases, the landmark is remembered for something other than who it is named for.

Take the Edmund Pettus Bridge. Named for a Confederate general and a Klan Grand Dragon (thanks, Wikipedia), it is best known as the site of the Selma March led by Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

Don’t change the name. We should be elated by the fact the bridge is known for ideals its namesake vehemently opposed.

6. Let's not forget that the North and West is/has been just as racist as the South, if not more so. The most infamous race riots in American History all took place in Northern cities. That riot at the end of Gangs of New York? White mobs burned down a Black orphanage and killed 11 men over the course of 5 days. Have we forgotten about the Internment Camps? Here, learn a little bit about Alvarez vs. Lemon Grove.

Do not be deceived - American racism is not encapsulated in the Confederate flag. The Stars & Stripes do that just fine.